Best Prop/Special Effect, 1999-2000
The pier that turned into an airplane, Steel Pier

Best Costume Design, 1999-2000
Joan Korastinsky, Steel Pier

Best Lighting Design, 1999-2000
Thom Johnson, Steel Pier

Best Set Design, 1999-2000
Kevin Brewer and Melissa Johnson, Crucible

John Rae Cameo Award, 1999-2000
Steve Miller (Buddy), Steel Pier

Best Actor in a Featured Role, 1999-2000
Curt Waugh, A Chorus Line

Best Actress in a Featured Role, 1999-2000
Amy Kullenberg, Angels in America

Best Actor, 1999-2000
Chris O'Brien, Angels in America

Best Actress, 1999-2000
Kathy Waugh, A Chorus Line

Best Director, 1999-2000
Melissa Johnson, Crucible

Best Director of a Musical, 1999-2000
Ron Baumanis, Steel Pier

Best Musical, 1999-2000
A Chorus Line

Best Play, 1999-2000
Angels in America Part One: Millennium Approaches

-----------------------------
Best Prop/Special Effect, 2000-2001
Mike Sielaff, Audrey 2, Little Shop of Horrors

Best Costume Design, 2000-2001
Joan Korastinsky, Front Page

Best Lighting Design, 2000-2001
Thom Johnson, Last Night of Ballyhoo

Best Set Design, 2000-2001
Glenn Bugala, Front Page

John Rae Cameo Award, 2000-2001
Michael Roehrig (Peachy), Last night of Ballyhoo

Best Actor in a Featured Role, 2000-2001
Charles Sutherland, Front Page

Best Actress in a Featured Role, 2000-2001
TIE: Laurel Huffano, Front Page
Francyn Chomic, Last Night of Ballyhoo

Best Actor, 2000-2001
Carl Hanna, Front Page

Best Actress, 2000-2001
Kathy Waugh, Evita

Best Director, 2000-2001
Chris Starkey, Last Night of Ballyhoo

Best Production, 2000-2001
The Front Page