Go to "My One and
Only" Home Page
"My One and Only" Preview
Musical aims for that classic feel
Thursday, June 3, 2004
BY JENN MCKEE News Arts Writer
To say that the Ann Arbor Civic Theatre's newest production, "My One and
Only," consists of the same old song and dance wouldn't offend director Ron Baumanis
in the least.
"I think this area is craving big, funny, old-fashioned musicals," Baumanis
said. "They're so pleasing to the audience and performers, but it seems like theaters
have gotten away from doing what they do best."
Baumanis, pointing to turgid Broadway productions like "Jekyll & Hyde,"
takes pains to steer his work in a very different direction. "Shows like that weren't
created to be done by community theater," he said. "They're all computerized.
It's so distancing that there's nothing to connect to. People come expecting big sets and
rock music, but that's not what the musicals are about."
Constructed around a collection of Gershwin tunes,
"My One and Only" - like its heroine, Edythe - has a complicated, checkered
past. In the 1980s, Peter Sellers helmed the first version of the show, hoping to bring
Russian deconstructionalism to Broadway. But not only did the show's star, dancer Tommy
Tune, voice apologies to the audience on the play's opening night in Boston, word of mouth
in New York soon renamed the show "My Flop and Phony."
So over the course of only a month, Tune and a dozen different writers re-worked the
songs, the scenes, the characters, and the choreography and, amazingly, they came up with
a winner.
"It opened on broadway the same year as 'Cats,' so it was very much the London
spectacle versus the very human, old-fashioned musical comedy," said Baumanis.
The show - which Baumanis calls "music with a script thrown in" - tells the
story of Edythe Herbert, a channel swimmer-turned-showgirl, and Billy Buck Chandler, an
aviator from Texas who dreams of flying from New York City to Paris. Set in 1927, Edythe
finds herself trapped in a relationship with her boss, Prince Nikki, while Billy's female
mechanic, Mickey, throws a wrench in the works of Billy and Edythe's romance.
"I love the show's energy, joy and music," said Michael Mahoney, the
University of Michigan theater student who plays Billy. "It's very tiring. There's a
lot of running around, and it requires a lot of quick thinking and energy. When I get home
from rehearsals all I can do is sleep. But it's wonderfully exhilarating at the same
time."
Allison Pearlman, a Western Michigan student who plays Edythe, found a different sort
of challenge in the play: "The songs may sound simple, but there are a lot of
difficult rhythms and difficult lyrics."
And although the demanding amount of choreography has also taxed the cast, Pearlman
noted, "It sounds so cool when we're on stage and tapping in synch."
Even the scene changes are choreographed, such that the actors sometimes dance with
props and set pieces. A 13-piece orchestra provides the production's music, and the
stylized, art deco set, accented with silver, gives the impression of an old black and
white film.
"(Baumanis) did a great job of creating the world of this show," said
Mahoney.
"It's a real throwback," said Baumanis. "There's no doubt from the
first strain that you're in for a night of Gershwin. The show's not done much because it's
so dance reliant, and it demands performers who are dancers, singers and actors. But in
Ann Arbor, we're darn lucky. We have them."